Skip to content

The Old Sacristy Sky in Florence: Which Day Did Brunelleschi Paint?

Sun, Moon, planets, and constellations above the Medici altar: a sky frozen on one exact day that scholars have been hunting for over a century

Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published

In Florence, inside the basilica of San Lorenzo, there's a small square room the Medici built as their family chapel. Above the altar, in a recess, a little dome about thirteen feet across is painted blue: gold stars, the Sun, the Moon, a few planets, and the figures of the constellations. This isn't just any sky. The positions are so precise that you can work out the day they show.

The trouble is that nobody wrote it down. No document tells us who painted that sky, who calculated its positions, or why. For more than a century art historians and astronomers have tried to date it, and their answers don't agree. Here's what we know, what's still debated, and what the math says.

Giovanni di Bicci's sacristy

The Old Sacristy (Sagrestia Vecchia) began as a family funerary chapel. The banker Giovanni di Bicci de' Medici commissioned it, and Filippo Brunelleschi, the man behind the dome of Florence Cathedral, designed it. According to archival research, work began around 1422. An inscription at the base of the lantern bears the date 1428, and the altar the date 1432.

Giovanni died in February 1429, before his sacristy was finished: "The sacristy had not yet been roofed over when Giovanni de' Medici passed from this life," writes Giorgio Vasari. His son Cosimo, later known as Cosimo the Elder, completed the rest. Donatello made the large roundels, the reliefs above the doors, and the bronze doors; in the middle of the room, under a marble table, lies the tomb of Giovanni and his wife, Piccarda Bueri.

Next to the main hall, with its umbrella dome, is a small chapel holding the altar: the scarsella. That's where the sky is.

A piece of sky above the altar

The little dome of the scarsella is painted a secco, on dry plaster: a background of azurite, stars and planets in gold leaf, and the constellation figures modeled in lead white. It shows half of the celestial sphere, mostly the part north of the celestial equator.

Among the figures runs a grid of gold lines: the celestial equator, the two tropics, the Arctic Circle, the two colures (the circles that pass through the poles and through the equinox and solstice points), and the band of the zodiac, about 12 degrees wide, with the ecliptic, the Sun's path among the stars, running down its middle. Along the ecliptic a row of tiny squares marks the degrees one by one, thirty to a sign.

According to the Museo Galileo, besides the Sun and the Moon, Jupiter and Venus are picked out in gold. And the sky is seen from the inside, as we see it from the ground, while the celestial globes of the time usually showed it from the outside.

Three dates for one sky

The first to attempt the calculation was Aby Warburg, the Hamburg art historian who a year later would unlock the decans of Palazzo Schifanoia. In 1911, with help from an astronomer, he proposed July 9, 1422, the day on which, he believed, the high altar of San Lorenzo had been consecrated.

Later, Gertrud Bing, Warburg's collaborator, set that date aside in favor of a calculation by the astronomer Arthur Beer: July 6, 1439, the day Florence held the solemn closing of the council that reunited the Latin and Greek Churches. In 1981 the art historian Patricia Fortini Brown took up and developed this reading in an article in the Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes. The historian of science John Heilbron, working independently, also arrived at July 6, 1439, around noon.

In 1987 a group of Florentine scholars (Forti, Lapi Ballerini, Monsignori Fossi, and Ranfagni) studied the painted planets in detail and proposed a different date: July 4 or 5, 1442. That's the date you'll find today in the Museo Galileo's entries and, for the twin sky in the Pazzi Chapel, in those of the Opera di Santa Croce.

On October 20, 2022, Italy's National Institute for Astrophysics (INAF), the Italian Society for Archaeoastronomy, and the Museo Galileo devoted a study day to the two skies. The program summed up the state of research like this: the hypotheses now come down to two dates, July 6, 1439, and July 4 or 5, 1442, "both supported by analysis of the star map."

Running the numbers again

How can two dates three years apart compete for the same sky? We calculated the positions using modern ephemerides. Mind the calendar: in the 1400s Florence used the Julian calendar, which at the time ran nine days behind ours. July 6, 1439, in Florence corresponds to our July 15.

The result explains the dilemma:

  • July 6, 1439: the Sun at about 22 degrees Cancer, the Moon in the late degrees of Taurus, a thin waning crescent a few days before the New Moon.
  • July 4, 1442: the Sun at about 20 degrees Cancer, the Moon again in late Taurus, again a waning crescent.

The Sun and the Moon sit in almost the same spot; the planets are what change. In July 1439 Jupiter was in Capricorn and Venus in Leo; in July 1442 Jupiter was in Taurus and Venus in Cancer, not far from the Sun. That's why the 1439 date rests mainly on the Sun and the Moon, while the 1987 study, which started from the planets, landed on 1442.

To an astrologer of the 1400s, that Moon also carried a precise meaning: in Taurus the Moon is in exaltation, one of the most favorable conditions it can be in.

1439: "Let the heavens rejoice"

The council had opened in Ferrara and moved to Florence in early 1439, partly because the city, which is to say Cosimo de' Medici, had offered to cover its costs. On July 6, 1439, Pope Eugene IV issued the bull of union with the Greeks, read out in Florence Cathedral, Santa Maria del Fiore. It opens with a line from the Psalms: Laetentur caeli et exultet terra, "Let the heavens rejoice, and let the earth be glad."

If this is the right date, the sky above the Medici altar recalls Cosimo's day of greatest glory: Florence at the center of Christendom, the Byzantine emperor and the pope in the same cathedral. And rejoicing heavens painted above an altar would be almost a quotation of the bull. The union didn't last long, but the link between that day and the little dome remains one of the two leading hypotheses.

1442: René of Anjou and the Pazzi Chapel

Those who favor 1442 usually connect it to René of Anjou, who in June of that year had lost Naples to Alfonso of Aragon. According to the Museo Galileo's entry, the sky commemorates his arrival in Florence, seen as a good omen. This too remains a hypothesis: no document ties the fresco to him.

René's name leads to the other sky, the nearly identical one in the Pazzi Chapel, in the cloister of Santa Croce. There too a little dome above the altar, there too a design by Brunelleschi, there too the same sky. The chapel belonged to Andrea de' Pazzi, a friend of René of Anjou: in 1442 one of Andrea's grandsons was baptized in the king's presence and named Renato in his honor. Some scholars think this bond explains why the Pazzi wanted the same date.

The two skies aren't the same, though. The organizers of the 2022 study day call the Santa Croce sky a copy that is "artistically and scientifically inferior." The Pazzi Chapel is also later: construction began in 1443.

Who painted it, who did the math

The painter is unknown. In 1969 the art historian Federico Zeri put forward Giuliano d'Arrigo, known as Pesello, a Florentine painter and decorator who passed away in 1446; scholar Isabella Lapi Ballerini revived the idea after the dome's restoration in the 1980s, and the Museo Galileo accepts it. Others consider it unproven.

For the astronomy, the name that comes up most often is Paolo dal Pozzo Toscanelli, a Florentine physician, mathematician, and cosmographer whose ties to Brunelleschi are documented by the architect's biographer, Antonio Manetti. According to an entry in Italy's national catalog of cultural heritage, the idea of painting the sky in the two little domes probably came from Brunelleschi himself, with Toscanelli helping to place the stars and planets.

One clue in Toscanelli's favor comes from the measurements. Half the angle between the two painted tropics is 23 degrees 30 minutes: the tilt of the ecliptic that, according to a letter by the astronomer Regiomontanus, Toscanelli and Leon Battista Alberti said they had found through their own observations. Ptolemy, the authority for every astronomer of the time, gave a higher value, close to 24 degrees.

Today's measurements

In February 2023, with permission from the Opera Medicea Laurenziana, Manuela Incerti of the University of Ferrara and her colleagues surveyed the sacristy with two laser scanners and photogrammetry, building a 3D model of the little dome. The first results, published in 2024, show that:

  • the dome is almost a perfect sphere, 3.96 meters (13 feet) across, and one degree of the painted sky measures about 3.4 centimeters (1.3 inches);
  • the gap between the painted lines and the theoretical ones never exceeds half a degree, or 1.7 centimeters (about two-thirds of an inch): remarkable precision for a 15th-century building site;
  • the axis of the painted sphere follows the axis of the room, which isn't oriented exactly north to south. The builders chose architectural harmony over faithfulness to the real sky.

A second paper, published in 2025 in the history of science journal Nuncius, compares the measurements with Ptolemy's Almagest and with Toscanelli's charts. The stated next step is to measure the positions of the stars and planets with the same care: that could help decide between 1439 and 1442.

Why a sky above an altar

Starry vaults in churches had existed for centuries, but they were symbolic skies. What's new at San Lorenzo is a scientific sky, with the positions of one specific day. The Museo Galileo sums up its purpose in two words: astrological and commemorative.

It's the same principle behind the birth chart and electional astrology: an important moment has its own sky, and that sky describes it. For the Medici, who would later ask even Galileo for horoscopes, painting the stars of a day of triumph, or of a day believed to be auspicious, above the family altar meant preserving its sky.

The sky of your own day

Step into the Old Sacristy and look up above the altar, and you see an instant from almost six centuries ago: a Sun in Cancer, a crescent Moon in Taurus, and the planets right where the sky's designer put them.

Every day has its own sky, including the day you were born. Your birth chart does exactly what the painters of San Lorenzo did: it captures the positions of the Sun, the Moon, and the planets at one precise moment, seen from one precise place. And if you want to know how another great Florentine looked at the sky, there's the article on Dante and the stars.

← All articles