Skip to content

The Most Stubborn Zodiac Signs, Ranked from Most Flexible to Most Headstrong

Fixed signs, Saturn, Mars and the Sun: who changes their mind in an afternoon, who stands their ground and who won't budge an inch, from 12th place to 1st

Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published

Some people change their minds three times before ordering at a restaurant; others have ordered the same dish for fifteen years. Some admit a mistake with a shrug; others would rather miss the train than say "you were right." So which is the most stubborn sign in the zodiac?

We'll answer with astrology and a bit of humor. Here, stubborn means not changing your mind, not dropping a project, sticking to your habits. It isn't jealousy, which is attachment to people (that one gets its own ranking of the most jealous signs): stubbornness is attachment to your own ideas. And we're talking about your sun sign, which is only one part of your personality.

The criterion: fixed signs, Saturn, Mars and the Sun

We weighed three factors, in this order:

  • Modality. This is the main factor, and it splits the ranking into three tiers. The fixed signs (Taurus, Leo, Scorpio, Aquarius) fall in the middle of each season: they're built to keep what's already there. Cardinal signs open the seasons: they have plenty of willpower, but they spend it on getting started, and if they need to, they change course. Mutable signs close the seasons: they're built to adapt.
  • Rulers and their dignities. Saturn, the slowest of the planets you can see with the naked eye, is constancy and rigidity; Mars is the will that doesn't back down; the Sun is pride, which makes it hard to admit a mistake. At the other end, Mercury and Jupiter, the rulers of the four mutable signs, bring curiosity and tolerance. A planet in domicile or exaltation leaves its full mark; in detriment or fall it's weakened.
  • Element. Earth is the element that moves the least, and fire has the strength of conviction. Air and water are more fluid, and their stubbornness, when it shows up, is about principles or memories (the elements are explained in this article).

Modality sets the tier; rulers and element set the order within it. Here's the ranking, from the most flexible sign to the most stubborn.

12th place: Gemini

Mutable air, the home of Mercury: Gemini changes its mind as easily as it changes the subject. It welcomes a good counterargument with enthusiasm, and ten minutes later it's defending it better than you did. The downside is that today it argues for what it was arguing against yesterday, without even noticing. The upside is that you can always reason with Gemini.

11th place: Pisces

Mutable water, the home of Jupiter in traditional astrology, with Venus in exaltation: Pisces combines the most fluid element with the most adaptable modality. It doesn't dig in its heels: it flows around the obstacle, like water around a stone. The downside is that sometimes it says yes and then does things its own way. The upside is that it knows how to put itself in the shoes of people who see things differently.

10th place: Virgo

Mutable earth, ruled by Mercury, which is in both domicile and exaltation here: it's the only planet with both dignities in the same sign. Earth makes it tenacious about method: for Virgo, there's a right way to load the dishwasher, and it's Virgo's way. But a Mercury this strong makes it rethink everything when new data comes in. The downside is digging in over details. The upside is that if you prove it wrong, it admits it.

9th place: Sagittarius

Mutable fire, the home of Jupiter, with Mercury in detriment: Sagittarius is the most convinced of the mutable signs. Fire gives it faith in its own truths, and a weak Mercury gives it little patience for objections. But it's a mutable sign, ruled by the planet of broad horizons: the theory it was defending in June, it has already outgrown by September. The downside is that, as long as it believes something, it preaches to everyone. The upside is that it never stays stuck in the same prejudice.

8th place: Cancer

Cardinal water, the home of the Moon, with Saturn in detriment and Mars in fall: Cancer lacks exactly the two planets that help you stand your ground in an argument, and sure enough, it doesn't dig in, it retreats. But it has the stubbornness of its claws: family habits, the usual restaurant, the way Christmas is celebrated are not up for discussion. The downside is a quiet resistance to anything new that touches home. The upside is that it keeps the traditions everyone else forgets.

7th place: Libra

Cardinal air, the home of Venus, with the Sun in fall and Mars in detriment: Libra always sees the other person's side, sometimes so many sides that it can't choose. But Saturn is exalted here, and that's what lifts it above Cancer: on what's fair, it won't move. The downside is indecision about everything else. The upside is a sense of justice that doesn't bend.

6th place: Aries

Cardinal fire, the home of Mars, with the Sun in exaltation: Aries is hardheaded by definition, and its symbol solves problems by butting heads. But it's a cardinal sign, and Saturn is in fall here: its stubbornness is intense and short. Today it defends its position against everyone; tomorrow it has already charged off to another battle. The downside is digging in before it has listened. The upside is that once the game is over, it doesn't sulk.

5th place: Capricorn

The home of Saturn, an earth sign, with Mars in exaltation: Capricorn is the cardinal sign that most resembles a fixed one. It sets a ten-year goal and reaches it one step at a time. What keeps it out of the top four is its modality: it's stubborn about the destination, not the route, and if a plan isn't working, it changes the plan. The downside is that it gives up on a goal only when it's impossible, and sometimes not even then. The upside is that what it starts, it finishes.

4th place: Leo

Fixed fire, the home of the Sun: Leo is stubborn out of pride. Changing its mind isn't the hard part; doing it in front of everyone is. But Saturn is in detriment here, so Leo lacks the cold rigidity of the other fixed signs: with a little warmth and the recognition it deserves, it can be won over, as long as the idea seems to be its own. The downside is that it won't admit a mistake out loud. The upside is its loyalty to the causes it takes up.

3rd place: Scorpio

Fixed water, the home of Mars in traditional astrology (and of Pluto in modern astrology): Scorpio doesn't change its mind, and above all it doesn't change its mind about people. Mars in domicile gives it the will to see things through, and fixed water a memory that loses nothing. It listens, nods and keeps its own opinion. The downside is that it rarely grants a second chance, to an idea or to a person. The upside is a tenacity that never wears out.

2nd place: Aquarius

Second place may come as a surprise: Aquarius has a reputation as the rebel of the zodiac. But it's a fixed sign, and in traditional astrology it's the home of Saturn. Its fixity is about ideas more than people: that's why it landed near the bottom of the most jealous signs, and why it's near the top here. It has thought its convictions through at length, and it considers them final: you can argue with Aquarius for hours, and in the end it will calmly explain why you're wrong. The downside is that even nonconformity, for Aquarius, becomes a rule. The upside is consistency: it won't betray its principles for convenience.

1st place: Taurus

We say "stubborn as a mule," but astrology has a different animal in mind. Taurus is fixed earth: the heaviest element in the most stable modality. It doesn't need Saturn or Mars to stand its ground; in fact, Mars is in detriment here, and Taurus doesn't fight: it simply doesn't move. That's stubbornness in its purest form, passive resistance. The Moon in exaltation ties it to its habits, Venus in domicile to what it knows and likes. The downside is that Taurus always decides when it's time for a change. The upside is a steadiness that never runs out: once it picks a road, it follows it to the end.

How stubborn are you, really?

Beyond your sun sign, stubbornness shows up in other parts of your chart: in Saturn, which shows where you're steady (and where you're rigid); in Mars, which shows how you defend a position; and in Mercury, which shows how easily you can be persuaded. How many planets you have in fixed signs matters too: a Gemini with Mercury and Mars in Taurus is much less pliable than the ranking suggests, and a Taurus with the Moon and Mercury in Gemini much more. Your rising sign changes how your firmness comes across to others, and compatibility between two signs shows whether two stubborn streaks respect each other or clash. To find out where your planets are, you can calculate your birth chart for free and read about your planets in the signs.

← All articles