Skip to content

The Most Loyal Zodiac Signs (and the Least), Ranked from Most Fickle to Most Faithful

Fixed and mutable signs, Venus, the Moon and Saturn: who moves on, who keeps their word and who stays for good, from 12th place to 1st

Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published

There's the friend you hear from once a year who picks up the phone as if you'd seen each other yesterday. There's the one who swears eternal friendship at a party and a month later can't remember your name. And there's the one who's had the same favorite bar, the same group of friends and the same partner for twenty years. So which is the most loyal sign in the zodiac?

A quick clarification: "loyal" here doesn't only mean faithful in a relationship. It means steady and true in all your bonds, with a partner as much as with friends, family and your own word. And no sign is unfaithful by nature: the ones at the bottom just need more room to breathe, and they're often honest about exactly that. We're talking about your sun sign, which is one piece of the picture (the rest is at the end).

The criterion: modality, Venus, the Moon and Saturn

Loyalty has two ingredients: constancy, the ability to stay, and attachment, the desire to stay. For this ranking we looked at four things:

  • Modality. This one carries the most weight. The fixed signs (Taurus, Leo, Scorpio, Aquarius) sit in the heart of each season: they're built to last. Cardinal signs open the seasons and love beginnings; mutable signs close them and love change. It's no accident that tradition also calls the mutable signs "double-bodied."
  • Venus and the Moon. Venus is the bond you choose, the Moon the bond you need: routine, a home base, the people who've always been there. Where they're comfortable, in domicile or exaltation, people get attached easily and for a long time; in detriment or fall the affection is there, but it takes more effort.
  • Saturn. Saturn is the planet of endurance and of keeping your word: where it's strong, a commitment stays a commitment even when it's no longer convenient.
  • Element. Earth holds on to what it has, water bonds and remembers; fire is always looking for the next challenge, and air needs to keep moving (the four elements are compared in this article).

Here's the ranking, from the most fickle sign to the most loyal.

12th place: Gemini

Mutable air, the home of Mercury, and no dignity at all for Venus, the Moon or Saturn: Gemini has every sign of change and none of permanence. It has a hundred friends and gives each of them a little slice of attention. The downside is that a new friendship excites Gemini more than an old one. The upside is that it never holds a grudge, and when it comes back, it's as if it never left.

11th place: Sagittarius

Mutable fire, the home of Jupiter, with a symbol that's half human and half horse: a double-bodied sign right down to its image. Sagittarius stays loyal as long as the relationship leaves the road open; the moment it senses a fence, it's gone. The downside is vanishing for three months and then sending you a postcard from who knows where. The upside is honesty: it never promises what it can't deliver.

10th place: Aries

Cardinal fire, the home of Mars, with Venus in detriment and Saturn in fall: affection and constancy are both struggling here. Aries dives into every relationship with huge enthusiasm, but gets bored once the chase is over. The downside is the rush to get to the next challenge. The upside is courage: if a friend is in trouble, Aries is the first to show up.

9th place: Virgo

Mutable earth, ruled by Mercury, with Venus in fall: earth makes Virgo reliable when it comes to practical things, while its mutable modality leads it to reassess relationships the way it reassesses everything else. The downside is that when a relationship stops working, Virgo notices before anyone else and ends it with a list of reasons. The upside is being there: when you ask for help, Virgo shows up, and shows up prepared.

8th place: Pisces

A water sign with Venus in exaltation, but mutable and double-bodied: the two fish in its symbol swim in opposite directions. Pisces loves with total devotion, and that's exactly why it finds it so hard to say no to anyone who needs it. The downside is that its heart has many rooms, and sometimes it gets lost in them. The upside is forgiveness: with Pisces there's always a second chance.

7th place: Leo

Fixed fire, the home of the Sun: for Leo, loyalty is a matter of honor, and its fixity keeps it where it gave its word. What holds it back is fire and Saturn in detriment, which make commitments that don't bring any satisfaction feel heavy. The downside is that Leo's loyalty needs feeding: if it feels neglected, it starts looking around. The upside is that a Leo friend stays your biggest fan forever.

6th place: Cancer

The home of the Moon, a water sign: Cancer is loyal to its roots, its family, its friends from grade school. What keeps it in the middle of the ranking is its cardinal modality and Saturn in detriment: its constancy follows its mood, and the mood of the Moon's sign shifts with the lunar phases. The downside is retreating into its shell for weeks when it feels hurt. The upside is that it never forgets who was there during the hard times.

5th place: Aquarius

The least jealous fixed sign in our jealousy ranking turns out to be one of the most loyal, because not jealous doesn't mean not loyal. Aquarius has the staying power of a fixed sign and, in traditional astrology, is Saturn's other home: loyal to its ideas, its friends and the groups it belongs to, often for decades. What keeps it off the podium is air: in a relationship it asks for space, and its loyalty looks more like friendship than romance. The downside is a certain distance. The upside is that once Aquarius considers you one of its people, you stay that way for life.

4th place: Libra

A surprise for anyone who pictures Libra as indecisive and a bit of a flirt. Libra is the home of Venus and the sign where Saturn is exalted: the planet of bonds and the planet of keeping your word, both at their best. What holds it back is its cardinal air modality: it likes to be liked, and sometimes it hesitates too long before choosing. The downside is a friendliness toward everyone that can come across as ambiguous. The upside is that once it has made a decision, it honors it.

3rd place: Capricorn

The home of Saturn, an earth sign: Capricorn promises little and delivers everything, and treats a relationship like a house to build year after year. It doesn't climb higher because the Moon is in detriment here, so its affection rarely shows; and because, as a cardinal sign, it sometimes puts its plans ahead of people. The downside is forgetting to tell you how much you mean to it. The upside is that, where it counts, it won't let you down.

2nd place: Scorpio

Fixed and water: fixity gives it constancy, water gives it attachment. Venus in detriment and the Moon in fall don't make it inconstant: they make its affection intense and complicated, never light. Scorpio chooses very few people, and with those it goes all the way, in love as in friendship. The downside is that it expects the same loyalty in return, and it never forgets a betrayal. The upside is that when Scorpio says "I'm here," it will be.

1st place: Taurus

Taurus has it all: it's fixed and earth, the steadiest of the four fixed signs; it's the home of Venus, which binds it to what it loves; and the Moon is exalted here, giving it a craving for routine and for the people who've always been there. Taurus doesn't change restaurants, doesn't change barbers, doesn't change friends, and if it has chosen you, it has no intention of reconsidering. The downside is resisting change even when change would help. The upside is that you always know where to find it.

Beyond your sun sign

This ranking looks at your sun sign, but loyalty shows up more clearly elsewhere in the chart: in Venus, which describes how you bond; in the Moon, which describes how much stability you need; and in Saturn, which describes how you handle commitments. A Gemini with Venus in Taurus can be far steadier than its 12th place suggests; a Taurus with the Moon in Sagittarius far more freedom-loving. Your rising sign also changes how you bond with others, and compatibility between two signs shows whether two different rhythms can last together. To find out where your planets are, you can calculate your birth chart for free and read about your planets in the signs.

← All articles