Skip to content

Galileo the Astrologer: Horoscopes for the Medici and Cosimo II's Jupiter

Paid birth charts, horoscopes for his daughters, a report to the Inquisition, and the Medicean Stars: the side of Galileo the textbooks leave out

Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published

In Florence, on the facade of the house of Vincenzo Viviani, Galileo's last pupil and first biographer, a Latin inscription honors the master as inanis artis genethliacae perpetuo insectatori: "the relentless foe of the empty art of horoscopes." In 1881 the historian Antonio Favaro, who would go on to edit the National Edition of Galileo's works, published an essay titled Galileo astrologo ("Galileo the Astrologer") and called that line, flatly, a lie.

The papers prove him right. Galileo Galilei, the father of the scientific method, cast birth charts: for students, for friends, for his daughters, for himself, and for the Grand Dukes of Tuscany. According to the historian Nick Kollerstrom, about twenty-five survive in his own hand, kept at the National Central Library of Florence in a bundle of some fifty pages with a modest title: Astrologica nonnulla, "a few astrological things."

A Mathematician, and So an Astrologer

In Galileo's day the mathematicus taught geometry, calculated the motions of the planets, and interpreted them too: astronomy and astrology were two sides of the same trade, as the article on Dante and the stars also shows. Among Galileo's manuscripts, according to Favaro, is a copy of Porphyry's introduction to Ptolemy's Tetrabiblos, the great handbook of traditional astrology, annotated in his own hand and most likely studied in Pisa when he was young.

From 1592 to 1610 Galileo held the chair of mathematics at the University of Padua, which had a long tradition of medical astrology. In two letters from 1609 he writes that most of his students were studying medicine: physicians of the time needed to know how to cast a chart for the moment a patient took to bed.

Then there were private clients, whom Galileo recorded in a little book of income and expenses. Among the entries for 1603 are payments from foreign students logged under a curious formula, per sortem, "for fortune." Favaro suspected these were horoscopes, and he found proof when he came across, among the astrological papers, the chart of one of those clients, Cristoforo Stettner, in Galileo's handwriting. If Favaro's math is right, a horoscope by Galileo cost sixty Venetian lire.

Friends asked too. The Venetian nobleman Giovanfrancesco Sagredo, who would become a character in the Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, sent him birth data to work out without any preamble, like someone who had done it many times before. In 1618 even Cardinal Alessandro d'Este asked him for a nativity.

Galileo's Own Birth Chart

The pages of the Astrologica nonnulla also hold two charts for his own birth, in Pisa in February 1564, cast half an hour apart. Above them Galileo noted the time in two ways: Italian style, counting the hours from the previous sunset, and French style, from noon. The planets are the same; what changes is the degree of the Ascendant, which falls in Leo in both versions. It was the age-old problem: the Ascendant needs an exact time, as the article on how to find your birth time explains. Next to the planets Galileo also wrote their latitudes, which are needed for primary directions, the technique used to follow the years of a life. According to Kollerstrom, these charts point to February 16 as his birthday, not the February 15 usually given: the mix-up would come from that very habit of counting hours from sunset.

Virginia and Livia

Galileo never married. With Marina Gamba, a Venetian woman, he had three children: Virginia, born in Padua in 1600; Livia, born the following year; and Vincenzo. For the two girls he cast birth charts and wrote a judgment of their character, texts that Favaro published in the National Edition but that biographers have almost always ignored.

For Virginia, the elder, her father saw a heavily debilitated Moon and a Saturn that gave her a serious air and strict habits, softened, however, by a well-placed Jupiter together with Mercury: a patient girl, capable of hard work, fond of solitude, a person of few words. For Livia he read a very strong rising Mercury conjunct Jupiter, promising knowledge, kindness, simplicity, humanity, and prudence.

The two sisters entered the convent of San Matteo in Arcetri, near Florence, while still very young, as Sister Maria Celeste and Sister Arcangela. Virginia became her father's confidante, as Dava Sobel tells in her book Galileo's Daughter. Livia, according to Sobel, turned out withdrawn and melancholy, rather far from what her father had read in the stars.

The 1604 Denunciation

Casting horoscopes wasn't forbidden, but there was a line: the Church accepted that the heavens influenced the body and temperament, not that they decided human actions. In April 1604 Silvestro Pagnoni, who had worked in Galileo's household as a copyist and had left on bad terms, went to the Inquisition in Padua. He accused his former employer of skipping Mass, of living with a woman he hadn't married, and of casting birth charts for wealthy clients while presenting his predictions as certain.

The charge drawn up by the Inquisition was that he had "reasoned that the stars, the planets, and the celestial influences necessitate," in other words, that he had claimed the stars compel. It was the very idea that Dante, three centuries earlier, had Marco Lombardo reject in the Purgatorio: the stars incline, they don't compel. But that was the end of it. The documents, found by the historian Antonino Poppi in the archives of Padua and Venice and published in the early 1990s, show that the Venetian government stepped in and the case was closed, with the charges judged to be of little weight. The Museo Galileo notes that the philosopher Cesare Cremonini, his colleague, was also reported in that same year of 1604, and that both came through unharmed.

The Horoscope for Grand Duke Ferdinando

The most famous episode is also the one told in the most different ways. In January 1609 the Grand Duke of Tuscany, Ferdinando I de' Medici, was seriously ill. His wife, Christina of Lorraine, wrote to Galileo, who had been tutoring her son Cosimo in mathematics for several summers. She asked him to use astrology to establish the Grand Duke's true moment of birth, which was uncertain, and to work out when his climacteric year would come, the year of life that tradition considered dangerous.

Galileo's reply survives: he describes casting the sky for both possible moments of birth with the Prutenic Tables, correcting the Sun's motion with Tycho Brahe's data. Ferdinando died in February 1609, twenty-two days after that letter according to Favaro.

Here the sources part ways. Favaro wrote that the letter closed with a flattering forecast, and popular books, Sobel's among them, often say that Galileo promised the Grand Duke many happy years. Kollerstrom, who edited the English edition of Favaro's essay, argues the opposite: the letter makes no prediction about Ferdinando's future, which no one had asked for, and offers only the hope that he would get through this time with God's help. What is certain is that the episode didn't cost Galileo the favor of the Medici.

Jupiter, Cosimo II, and the Medicean Stars

A few months later Galileo turned his telescope to the sky and, between late 1609 and early 1610, drew the Moon with mountains and craters no one had ever seen. The drawings are kept in Florence among the Galileo manuscripts, as Ms. Gal. 48. In the 1970s the historian of astronomy Owen Gingerich noticed that on those same pages, next to the Moon, were two birth charts that the National Edition had left out. He worked out their date, May 12, 1590, and in 1976 Guglielmo Righini realized whose they were: Cosimo II de' Medici's, the young man Galileo had taught mathematics and who had been the new Grand Duke since February 1609.

In Cosimo's chart, for a birth at "one hour of the night" (one hour after sunset) according to the court diary, Jupiter sat near the Midheaven, the highest point in the chart, the one tied to power and reputation. The Ascendant was in Sagittarius, the sign ruled by Jupiter itself. According to Kollerstrom, the first version, left unfinished, was cast about twenty minutes earlier than the second: Galileo may have chosen the later time partly because it brought Jupiter closer to the Midheaven.

The reason for all this work becomes clear in March 1610, when the Sidereus Nuncius, the "Starry Messenger," came out in Venice. The book announced four bodies circling Jupiter, named in honor of the Medici. In February Galileo had also suggested Cosmica Sidera, Cosimo's stars; in the end he chose Medicea Sidera, the Medicean Stars: four, like Cosimo and his three brothers.

The dedication to Cosimo is a small treatise on astrology. The new stars, Galileo writes in Latin, never stray from Jupiter's side, like offspring worthy of him. And who does not know, he goes on, that the clemency, gentleness of spirit, sweetness of manner, splendor of royal blood, majesty in action, and breadth of authority found in the Grand Duke flow "from the most benign star of Jupiter," by the will of God, the source of all good? He adds that at the moment of Cosimo's birth, Jupiter had already risen past the murky vapors of the horizon and was occupying the Midheaven, lighting up the eastern angle, that is, the Ascendant, from its royal throne. The four stars thus became the image of a family born under the king of the planets.

It worked. In July 1610 Cosimo II named Galileo mathematician and philosopher to the Grand Duke and brought him back to Tuscany. Meanwhile, that birth chart was making the rounds in Europe: according to Favaro it was known in Germany and Poland too, where in 1611 the king's secretary mentioned it in a letter to the Florentine court.

Did He Really Believe It?

The honest answer is that we don't know. In 1614 the philosopher Tommaso Campanella wrote to him from prison in Naples with a reproach: a prince he knew had told him that he'd asked Galileo for his own nativity, and that Galileo had refused, saying he didn't believe in it. Then why, Campanella asked, had he written to the Grand Duke that his virtues came from the Jupiter in his chart?

In the 1632 Dialogue, Salviati, Galileo's mouthpiece, pokes fun at astrologers' predictions that show up perfectly in the chart, but only after the fact. The following year, in a letter to his friend Elia Diodati, Galileo says he's amazed that the Frenchman Jean-Baptiste Morin, the most celebrated astrologer of the day, hopes to give astrology the certainty of a science with conjectures that seem to him uncertain, indeed very uncertain; he will wait, he adds, with great curiosity to see this marvel. Favaro already noted that those words are no outright condemnation, and Kollerstrom observes that Salviati's jab, too, targets those who predict after the event, not astrology itself.

He wasn't alone. Johannes Kepler, who in 1610 was among the first to defend the Sidereus Nuncius, was mathematician to Emperor Rudolf II and cast horoscopes as well: his 1608 chart for the general Albrecht von Wallenstein is famous. The historian Darrel Rutkin, in a 2005 study titled, fittingly, Galileo Astrologer, argues that Galileo practiced astrology for much of his life, as was normal for a mathematician of his time. That didn't make him a worse astronomer: anyone who cast charts by hand saw up close how inaccurate the planetary tables were. In Galileo's own chart, Kollerstrom notes, Mercury is off by four degrees.

The Sky of the Man Who Watched the Sky

Galileo was not the foe of astrology that Viviani wanted him to be, nor was he a professional astrologer. He was a man of his time who knew the art, practiced it, and knew how to use it, with political skill too: Cosimo II's Jupiter opened the road to Florence for him. For what today's science says about astrology, see the article on astrology and science.

Galileo cast his charts by hand, with imprecise tables and uncertain birth times; today it takes a minute. With your date, time, and place of birth you can calculate your birth chart and see where your Jupiter was when you were born: maybe not at the Midheaven like a Grand Duke's, but in a place all your own.

← All articles