Skip to content

Is Astrology a Science? What the Studies Actually Say

Carlson's test, the time twins, Gauquelin's Mars effect, the Forer effect and a study of 12,791 Americans: the results, told by an astrology site

Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published

Is astrology a science? It's one of the questions horoscope readers ask most often, usually after someone has asked them with a half-smile. From an astrology site you'd expect a one-sided answer. Let's try to give the honest one instead: no, not in the sense that physics or biology are. And we know why, because astrology has been put to the test many times.

That doesn't mean it has nothing to say. It means it's worth knowing what it is and what it isn't, and reading it for what it really is. Here are the best-known studies, what they found and what we make of them.

Two different things with the same name

First, a distinction that often gets lost. The astronomical part of astrology is precise and verifiable: where the Sun, the Moon and the planets are at a given moment, when a planet turns retrograde, when an eclipse falls. Those are calculations, and on this site we run them with an astronomy library, as we explain on the method page.

The interpretive part, on the other hand, says what those positions mean: that an Aries is impulsive, that Saturn brings trials, that Venus in the 7th house speaks of love. That's the part the studies put to the test. And so far, the results have been disappointing.

Carlson's test (1985)

The most famous is the one by physicist Shawn Carlson, published in 1985 in the journal Nature. It was a double-blind test, designed together with experienced astrologers who had agreed to the rules in advance. Each astrologer was given a birth chart and three personality profiles drawn from a psychological questionnaire: one really belonged to the person in the chart, the other two to strangers. All they had to do was pick the right one.

The astrologers had predicted they'd get it right at least half the time. They got it right about one time in three: exactly what you'd get by guessing. The test subjects, too, when asked to recognize the reading of their own chart among three, did no better than chance. Years later the German psychologist Suitbert Ertel reanalyzed the data and argued that some of the results were a little less clear-cut than they'd been presented; but nobody has turned that into evidence in astrology's favor.

The time twins

If the sky at birth really mattered, two people born at almost the same moment in the same place should resemble each other more than any two random people. Researchers Geoffrey Dean and Ivan Kelly checked this in 2003 with more than two thousand people born in London in early March 1958, often minutes apart, whom a British study had followed for decades.

They compared more than a hundred traits: personality, occupation, abilities, school results. The "time twins" were no more alike than people born on different days. It's one of the hardest results to get around, because it doesn't depend on how an astrologer reads the chart: the chart is the same.

Gauquelin's Mars effect

There's one case astrology's supporters often bring up, and it deserves to be told properly. In the 1950s the French psychologist and statistician Michel Gauquelin collected thousands of birth dates and times of famous people. He found that great sports champions were born slightly more often than expected with Mars just risen or just past its highest point in the sky: about 22% instead of the expected 17%.

The result was argued over for decades. A Belgian committee replicated it; an American study didn't, amid disputes over methods; a large French check, on more than a thousand athletes, didn't find the effect, and Gauquelin's supporters challenged how the names had been chosen. The question was never fully settled. But there's a detail that's often forgotten: Gauquelin also looked for the effects of signs and aspects, the stuff of astrology proper, and didn't find them. The Mars effect, if it exists, doesn't vindicate the horoscope.

The Forer effect: why your horoscope seems to be about you

In 1948 the American psychologist Bertram Forer had his 39 students take a personality test. A week later he gave each of them a "personal profile" and asked how accurate they found it, on a scale from 0 to 5. The average was 4.26. Only at the end did Forer reveal that the profile was the same for everyone, and that he'd taken most of the sentences from an astrology book bought at a newsstand: "You have a great need for other people to like and admire you," "At times you are extroverted, affable, sociable, while at other times you are introverted, wary, reserved."

It's been called the Forer effect (or Barnum effect) ever since: we tend to recognize ourselves in vague, flattering descriptions, especially when we believe they were written for us. It applies to horoscopes, but also to magazine quizzes and plenty of personality profiles. It's a good reason to read your horoscope with a sense of humor, and to be wary of anyone who promises to know everything about you from a date.

12,791 Americans and their sun signs

The most recent study is from 2024. Psychologist Mohsen Joshanloo used data from the General Social Survey, a large survey of the US population, to compare the zodiac sign of 12,791 adults with eight measures of well-being: mood, satisfaction with work and with one's financial situation, and how healthy people felt. The sign explained practically nothing. A random number from 1 to 12 worked about as well.

The study only covers the sun sign, which is a small part of the birth chart, as we explain in the article on how the newspaper horoscope was born. But the sun sign is exactly what almost all popular astrology is built on.

So why read your horoscope?

For the same reason people read Greek myths, the cards of an old tarot deck or Dante's Divine Comedy, which is full of stars: because astrology is a language. For more than two thousand years it has helped people put names to characters, to the seasons of life, to moments of change. Saturn coming back after 29 years, the Moon changing mood twelve times a month, Venus stopping and turning back: these are images that help us think about ourselves, even without believing the planets decide anything.

That's how we try to write it. The planetary positions are real, calculated to the minute; the rules are those of the tradition, laid out on the method page; the interpretations are prompts, not predictions, and they never replace the advice of someone who truly knows the field when it comes to your well-being, your money or big decisions. If a horoscope makes you pause for a moment to think about your week, it has done its job. If it promises that something will happen, be wary: not even the sky can do that.

If you want to go beyond your sun sign, you can calculate your birth chart and see how the planets were arranged at the moment you were born: a far richer picture than any horoscope by sign. We've covered other common misconceptions in our articles on the thirteenth sign, Ophiuchus, and on Mercury retrograde.

← All articles