Halloween Origins: Samhain, All Saints' Day, and the Midpoint of Autumn
From the Celtic new year to the Church's November 1 to Italy's sweets for the dead: what the sky has to do with it, and what it doesn't
Written and reviewed by GΛNMI · Published
Halloween, All Saints' Day, All Souls' Day: three holidays in three days, from October 31 to November 2. They look like they were born together, and in part they were. But the story is more tangled than the version that makes the rounds every fall, the one that traces everything back to an ancient Celtic rite "for talking with the spirits."
There is a thread tying these dates to the sky, and it's real: they fall halfway between the fall equinox and the winter solstice, while the Sun crosses the heart of Scorpio. The rest is a story of calendars, popes, monks, and almond cookies. It's worth separating what we know from what gets repeated.
A Holiday Halfway Through the Season
The solar year has four fixed points: the two equinoxes and the two solstices. Between them lie four midpoints, known as cross-quarter days. The medieval Irish calendar placed its four great seasonal festivals more or less there: Imbolc on February 1, Bealtaine on May 1, Lughnasadh on August 1, and Samhain on November 1.
These were calendar dates, not astronomical observations: the Irish sources fix them on the first day of the month, without measuring where the Sun is. The idea of a "Wheel of the Year" with eight festivals, four astronomical and four in between, is more recent: the neopagan movements of the twentieth century made it popular. Still, it works as an approximation, and the sky confirms it give or take a few days.
If you want the true midpoint, there are two ways to calculate it. In 2026 (all dates and times here are in Universal Time, UTC; depending on your time zone an event may fall a day earlier or later):
- September 23, 00:05: fall equinox, the Sun enters Libra.
- November 6, 22:28: the exact halfway point in time between equinox and solstice. The Sun is at 14°31' Scorpio.
- November 7, 09:52: the Sun reaches 15° Scorpio, the exact middle of the sign and of the stretch between the two points.
- December 21, 20:50: winter solstice, the Sun enters Capricorn.
The two midpoints are a few hours apart because Earth doesn't orbit the Sun at a constant speed. It comes closest to the Sun in early January (the next perihelion is January 3, 2027) and speeds up in these months: the Sun seems to move along the ecliptic a little faster, so it reaches 15° Scorpio after the halfway point in time. The same math works for the other cross-quarter days: in 2026 the Sun passed 15° Aquarius on February 3, 15° Taurus on May 5, and 15° Leo on August 7.
Either way, November 1 falls almost a week before the midpoint. That's the gap between a calendar made of months and a sky that doesn't care about months.
Samhain: What We Actually Know
Samhain appears in the oldest Irish texts, starting in the ninth century. It marked the end of the harvest and the start of the "dark" half of the year, the winter half, and it was the season of great gatherings: in the epic tales, many stories begin at a Samhain feast, when kings and warriors are assembled and have time on their hands.
A similar name turns up in Gaul. The Coligny calendar, a large bronze tablet from the second century AD found in France, has a month called Samon and, on its seventeenth day, the inscription trinox Samoni, "the three nights of Samon." It's unclear whether this is the same festival as the Irish one or a different one, and even the meaning of the word is debated: some scholars derive it from "summer," others from "gathering, assembly."
As for the dead, the sources are more cautious than the legend. The English historian Ronald Hutton, one of the most cited voices on the subject, notes that the oldest documents describe Samhain as a harvest festival, with no particular rites connected to the departed. The link with souls, ghosts, and visits from the other world grows stronger in later centuries, as Samhain and the Christian holidays of early November coexist and shape each other.
How All Saints' Day Landed on November 1
The feast of all the saints wasn't born in November. On May 13, 609 or 610, Pope Boniface IV consecrated Rome's Pantheon, the ancient temple of all the gods, to the Virgin and all the martyrs, and Rome kept that May anniversary for a long time.
The next step came from Gregory III, pope from 731 to 741, who dedicated a chapel in the old Basilica of St. Peter to the relics "of the holy apostles and of all saints, martyrs and confessors." Some sources date the dedication to November 1, others to Palm Sunday of 732. Around 800, churches in Northumbria, in northern England, were already celebrating all the saints on November 1, and the scholar Alcuin of York recommended the same date in Bavaria.
The date became universal in 835, when Emperor Louis the Pious, at the request of Pope Gregory IV, made November 1 a holy day of obligation throughout the Frankish Empire.
And Samhain? The idea that the Church picked November 1 to "Christianize" the Celtic festival goes back to the anthropologist James Frazer, around the turn of the twentieth century, and it's still the one you hear most. But it hasn't been proven. Hutton points out that the Irish church honored all the saints on April 20, and he sees November 1 as an idea from the Germanic and Anglo-Saxon world. Other scholars think Irish monks played a role. There is no evidence that the date was chosen to replace Samhain.
November 2 and the Birth of Halloween
The day for remembering the dead has a precise birth date. In 998 Odilo, abbot of the great monastery of Cluny in Burgundy, decreed that the monasteries of his order remember the dead on November 2, the day after All Saints. The custom then spread through the whole Western Church.
Halloween comes from here. The name is the Scottish form of All Hallows' Eve, "the eve of All Saints": October 31 is an eve, not a holiday of its own. In Scotland and Ireland, the night before All Saints filled up with folk customs: going door to door in disguise, recorded in Scotland from the sixteenth century; turnips hollowed out and carved with grotesque faces; the fortune-telling games Robert Burns described in a 1785 poem.
Irish and Scottish immigrants brought all of this to America in the nineteenth century, where pumpkins, bigger and easier to carve, replaced the turnips. The phrase "trick or treat" first appears in print in 1917, in a Canadian newspaper, and catches on in the 1930s. In the twentieth century, it's this American version that crossed the ocean again and reached Italy too.
Italy's Days of the Dead
In Italy, the nights between November 1 and 2 have customs of their own, much older than Halloween's arrival.
In Sicily, the feast of the dead was long the day children got presents. On the morning of November 2 they found sweets and toys brought, so they were told, by relatives who had passed away: the cannistru, a basket of dried fruit, ossa di morto ("bones of the dead," hard spiced cookies), marzipan fruit known as frutta martorana, and, in Palermo, the pupi di zucchero, brightly painted sugar figures that are hollow inside.
In Sardinia, it's the children who go from house to house on November 1 or 2, asking for an offering "for the souls" with traditional phrases in Sardinian. The custom changes its name from area to area: Is animeddas or Is panixeddas in the Campidano, Su mortu mortu in Nuoro, Su peti cocone in Baronia. It resembles trick-or-treating, but it doesn't come from it.
In many regions of central and northern Italy, starting with Rome, people bake fave dei morti, "beans of the dead," little almond cookies shaped like fava beans. Pellegrino Artusi, author of Italy's classic nineteenth-century cookbook Science in the Kitchen, includes them as "Roman beans, or beans of the dead," explaining that they "are customarily made for the commemoration of the dead" in place of real beans. He also recalls that in antiquity the fava bean was a funeral offering, believed to hold the souls of the departed. In Friuli, according to collections of folk customs, country households would leave a lamp burning, a bucket of water, and some bread overnight for the dead passing through.
Scorpio and the Eighth House
On the days of the dead the Sun is in Scorpio, and modern astrology ties this sign to the great themes of endings and passage: death, inheritance, transformation. The connection runs through the 8th house, the part of the birth chart that covers death, inheritance, and other people's resources, and Scorpio is the eighth sign.
It's worth knowing, though, that equating the eighth sign with the 8th house is a twentieth-century idea. In ancient and medieval astrology, signs and houses were separate things: Scorpio was the night domicile of Mars, a fixed water sign. The "house of death" was the 8th, whatever sign happened to fall there. Later, with the discovery of Pluto in 1930, named after the god of the underworld, many astrologers gave it rulership of Scorpio, and the sign took on the dark coloring it has today.
Read with some restraint, the pairing works: the season when nature sheds its leaves and people visit those who are gone is also the season of the sign that speaks of what we inherit and what changes form. There's no need to add ghosts.
This Year's Sky
2026 adds something of its own. Over the days of the dead, Mercury is retrograde, entirely in Scorpio:
- October 24: retrograde station at 20°58' Scorpio.
- November 1: Mercury is around 16° of the sign, moving backward by more than a degree a day.
- November 4: Mercury passes between Earth and the Sun, at 12° Scorpio.
- November 13: direct station at 5°02' Scorpio, at 15:56.
Mercury was also the god who guided souls to the underworld, and the coincidence is hard not to smile at. In astrology, more modestly, Mercury retrograde in Scorpio invites you to reread, to return to old questions, to rethink what was left hanging. How to read it without panic is covered in the article on Mercury retrograde. Venus is also retrograde until November 14, in Libra: the details are in the article on Venus retrograde.
On Halloween night the Moon is waning in Cancer; the last quarter arrives on the evening of All Saints' Day, at 20:28, in Leo. Then, on November 7, the Sun touches 15° Scorpio: the true midpoint between equinox and solstice. Two days later, on Monday November 9 at 07:02, comes the New Moon in Scorpio, at 16°53': the first lunar cycle to begin after the days of the dead. All of the month's phases are in the November Moon calendar.
The sky dates are calculated with the same astronomical model used for the horoscopes on this site. The others, the dates from history, are less precise and more debated, and that's how they should be told.